Thank you for your replies.
I will call/email them, but I'm not sure I'd get a reply from the graduate school. Yale's website more or less says you shouldn't call or email.
The majority of schools don't have this online status screen, I think this means that they'll email you if there is anything missing?
To weirdo: I wouldn't worry, one of my friends (from 2 years ago) was asked in Feb/March for her TOEFL scores. But since she had completed both her high school and university education in English, she told them that, and was admitted. I think, at least in this case, they only checked that everything was in order after they admit you. After all, their admission decision will in no way be based on TOEFL scores.
