Quote:
Originally Posted by israelecon
in any case, i actually asked a professor of mine about SEJ (because of this discussion and he said: "i would rather throw the article in the garbage than publish it there". i think this does say something about the article.
|
Can I draw a parallel?
Econ PhD admissions.
Someone saying they'd rather not go anywhere at all than go to a top 50 or whatever school.
Fine, that's some people's preferences (and it says as much about the person's preferences as it does about the quality).
But it's not the kind of thing that should be loudly exclaimed in public.