gprep - san antonio

[Linux]

E sounds wordy for me. D seems okay

[Fran Zgz]

In D

(1) The sentence reads like: In few cities ..., but the river .... This breaks parallelism to a certain extent (it should be few cities... but San Antonio...)
(2) The usage of comas is wrong 'cause arent necessary

I'd go for E

[vik_gmat]

It is E.

Author is trying to compare cities here, not river.
In D, sentence tries to compare the river in other cities to the river in san antonio.

[BigGameJames]

The Official Answer is E.

It was definitely down to D or E. I also picked E just because it "sounded better". But let's get a concrete reason to eliminate E.

I think D makes a correct comparison. A river in cities to the river in San Antonio.

[vik_gmat]

The Official Answer is E.

It was definitely down to D or E. I also picked E just because it "sounded better". But let's get a concrete reason to eliminate E.

I think D makes a correct comparison. A river in cities to the river in San Antonio.

BGJ,

D does make grammatically correct comparison, but don't you think that is not what author intended to say? (by changing the meaning).

[anotherlooser]

In A, B and C, the comparison is incorrect (river to river or cities to San Antonio).
Stat D changes the meaning.
Stat E is the best by POE.

[geekybiz1]

E it is.

D talks "In few US cities....., but the river in SA" which is non-parallel.

[prakul]

POE ...will go with E

[chatru]

Out of "D" and "E" i would go with "D"

[tamGmat]

The sentence talks about many cities or most cities.

Few cities in D alters the meaning. Moreover the sentence is awkward and
difficult to read. sounds like 3-4 phrases