1 out of 1 members found this post helpful.
Re: Profile Evaluation for PHD in Strategy or Marketing.
For a PhD, a GMAT of 600-650 is very low. I'm a Marketing PhD student, and my research interests are related to Marketing Strategy. Since you wrote you are interested in Strategy or Marketing, I guess your interests would be close to mine. And my GMAT score is 750. I recommend aiming at least 700.
It is still possible to be accepted with a score of 650, but the cases I have seen are for applicants with a strong profile despite the low GMAT. And I don't see that here. I guess a low GMAT with zero research experience will keep you out of most top 50 schools.
Even if you had a very strong profile, applying to only 3 schools would mean almost no possibility of an offer. Usually, people apply to at least 10 schools, on average probably around 15 schools.
And every time I see a list of dream schools that mention only famous schools, I get the feeling that the applicant didn't do much to identify which schools are the best for him/her. Applying to a school just because the school is famous is a bad strategy for PhD.
I may be wrong, but Harvard, Stanford, and MIT seem to me so different from each other, that I can't see how the same applicant would be a great fit for the three of them.
And you didn't really answer what made you want to pursue a PhD. What you wrote is probably true for every PhD student in Strategy, it does not tell anything about YOUR motivation since it is too generic.
The general feeling is that you haven't done much yet to make your profile strong enough and improve the odds.