I've been to both Italy (Florence and Milano) and Amsterdam. Milano is as boring as Amsterdam, but Florence is just amazing, one of the most beautiful cities in the world.
They wrote in fact: "we have postponed our deadline until April 15th."
So I believe for everyone who asked.
So I can go for EUI interview and think a little bit more. And Bocconi results will be out before the deadline as well. But still, 95% for TI (5% for falling in love with Florence or Milano)
guys i would like to know more about tilberg university...........sure its featured in the top 20 ........but is it cost effective? in terms of funding and scholarships available? and second thing.....wot is the usual cut-off for the gre and the toefl that this university asks for? as its kinda tough getting the actual scenario at the university? tilberg applicant and students ....please do let me know
guys....and wht are the chances of getting into a top notch US doctoral programme after doing an MA or an MPhil from a European Universuty? If it is good, which are the good european universities? How is EUI and bocconi?? UK seems to be pretty expensive.....very few scholarships and funding chances....do share your thougts guys....
Hey guys, having no energy for doing anything productive (good admits make me lazy ) i decided to read some old threads and pick up interesting posts about TI. Probably I haven't found all of them, so feel free to add more. What's more, some of them may be old, so comments from current TI students are more than welcomed.
"Tinbergen is extremely strong in labor economics and development. Free University is very strong in development. [ Have you never heard of Sow (SOW-VU) However, development economists are not solely working in the Development Economics group; the Stichting Onderzoek Wereldvoedselvoorziening (SOW - Centre for World Food Studies), and the Economic and Social institute (ESI) employ well known development economists as well. Due to the presence of these institutes, with whom the department collaborates on a regular basis, the Vrije Universiteit is one of the best places for the study of development economics.
Then, you also have SCHOLAR at University of Amsterdam..."
"GPA requirement of 7 is for scholarship in the second year of the Mphil Programme. If you have it at least 7, you can be sure you will retain the full scholarship. If you didn't get a full scholarship in the first year, and your GPA in the first year is at least 7, you can be (almost) sure to get the full scholarship for the second year. But even if you don't manage 7...there have been exceptions...but then it depends on the board, number of people and their financial situation.
If you pass a 2-year Mphil programme, then you practically don't have any limitations to progress to Phd. Basically, you just need to find your mentor. EUR and UvA so far haven't hdany GPA requirements. VU university usually each year accepts only 4 phd students and they have a requirement of GPA of at least 7...that's why there is some *** in the statement.
Statement "passing to phd at TI isn't a big issue" is correct for 2nd year onward. In the first year, they are quite brutal. in the past seeing 5-6 people leaving till February was not that unusual. But they were mostly dutch...and some of them left for other reasons (found out that much work was not for
them, found opportunity costs too big (free time reduction)...).
BTW 975 euros is the net value...you will not pay any taxes on it (at least not in the Netherlands and/or if you are EU resident).
If you get a full scholarship at Tinbergen (~50%), you will get tuition fee reimbursement (9.000 EUR if non-european, 1.500 EUR if from EU), EUR 955 per month for living expenses, max. EUR 40 per month for health insurance and all train travel costs for educational purposes reimbursed. Everybody that passes first year with gpa of at least 7 get a full scholarship for the second year, where you can also get a salary for TA in amount of around EUR 500 per month for 1 hour of TA per week. If you get a partial scholarship you get health insurance, tuition fee reimbursed and travel costs reimbursed.
"Of course, after 2 years, you may get a top10 acceptance..or not. However, be careful, it's easy to undermine your current profile with master grades. And in this respect note that Tinbergen's programme is very demanding (it's on the first-year Phd level and not on the usual master level) and probability of getting some bad grades is high. Dutch schools are known to be very economical when it comes to grading in general. Now, how much do adcoms in USA know for this is another question. TI is a very good place in its own right, tough...and I would say wherever you go you will be in good hands."
"My understanding of European Econ PhD programs was just turned around 180. Tinbergen's PhD program's placements rival those of US TOP 15 (which I did not think it would) with placements at Northwestern, Stern, University of Chicago and Cambridge for the last 2 years."
"Tinbergen Institute has a very strong and active group in Behavioral and Eexperimental Economics. If you are willing to go to Europe, I believe it is the best place o study Behavioral in the other side of the Atlantic. Take a look at the CREED website: CREED, Center for Experimental Economics in political
"some students from tinbergen do get out after the mphil and do go to other programmes... however, the institute doesn't want people to use the institute as a stepstone to other phd programes, so they just dont publish it... by the placement of the phd students (post docs at northwestern, chicago, cambridge...) you can imagine that with good lors you could go to a top 10 place..i dont study there but i know a couple of people that are in the phd program and they tell me that the majority of mphil students stay for th ephdm but every year one or to go out and no one know where they are! and since you ask letters for professors and not for the institute, if you have a good relation with professores i see no problem in applying to other phds... at least i would think it is just retarted if they screw you letter because you want to leave for another phd...
"I have received an e-mail from Tinbergen. They do not have a list for earlier graduates, but for the recent ones. Here I paste the related part:
"Of the most recent cohorts, our graduates have ended up in tenure-track positions in New York University (Stern School of Business), Indiana University (Kelley School of Business), University of Essex and Warwick Business School and as postdoc researchers at Northwestern University (Kellogg School of Management), Princeton University (Princeton Laboratory for Experimental Social Science) and the University of Chicago.""
"Tinbergen strictly dominates Bocconi in nearly all fields."
"The profs I know (pretty well known in europe and US) told me I shouldn't apply there: Placement is bad/nonexistent and even within the subset of european schools it's just mediocre ... so what does this tell you about your future possibilities? I mean you would spend (I don't want to say waste) 5 years of your life at a school that gives you only a slight comparative advantage on the non-private-sector job market.. is this worth the effort?"
"Isnīt Tinbergen too new to judge on its placement? My professors were telling me exactly the opposite of what you heard. In addition, I have a friend currently in the program and he is extremely positive about it. They care about their students, the overall atmosphere is friendly and the level of teaching very high according to what he said. I would for example choose it over Tilburg any time."
"I agree with veroniquaz! Let me try to clarify a few points:
1 - In The Netherlands a lot of people seem to think that a PhD is a temporary job (because it is indeed a paid job during research, and I guess you are highly subsidized during the MPhil) before you move on to the private sector.
2 - Dutch universities absorb a lot of its academic PhDs. They don't recruit massively in the international job market. In a sense, PhDs from Dutch universities are not the most international-academic-job seeking people, but probably that is more self-selection than anything else.
I don't see this as a drawback. Of course I am against inbreeding, but just because you come from Harvard or MIT it doesn't mean you are going to be a good researcher. I know a lot of examples where it did not.
3 - The TI placement is going to improve. TI has one of the better structured, most rigorous programmes in Europe (the established goal is for it to be taught at the US level). Definitely better than Tilburg from what I have been told. People at TI are really making an effort to admit mostly people who want to go into academia. You will work with very good researchers. They help people with placement. I don't see how it can go absolutely wrong.
4 - A great advantage of TI and Tilburg is the relationship you have with your advisor: relaxed, close and cooperative. You can publish with senior people with much more ease than in the US. Your advisor will have the time to give you good advice regarding your career.
5 - TI research output is currently better that Tilburg's. The non-adjusted-for-productivity ranking in Europe is currently (source: Repec-Ideas):
VU (Vrije Amst)
6 - Toulouse is a killer brand name, and you get to learn from and work with top and rather well known people. I think the only problem might be the very intense competition; students finishing the Masters and wiling to pursue the PhD exceed what the PhD is able to acommodate. I heard it can get very stressful and you might feel a bit lost. This does not mean you should not consider Toulouse. I am actually considering it in case I am admitted (revealed preference).
7 - An advantage of TI: the context/environment is very close to top US schools: small entering class, very busy and core-based first year, specialization + get out your ideas in the second year, if you maintain a decent standing you get a PhD position."
"2. Inside info on Tinbergen: non-competitive, friendly environment, almost all students (28-30 out of 30 in the first year) progress into second year. Also my own impression is very very good." veroniquaz: "Ad 2. According to my inside info (a good friend in the program) 7 people already have left the program this year. Agree with the rest."
1. You get your office at the university where your mentor works together with the salary. Usually you focus on research with some possible teaching obligations.
2. In the first week of september. Mphil ends with 1st July.
3. Yes, it's in fact encouraged. Recently a private fund has been established for travel expenses designed only for TI students. In the past people went also to very good ones (Upenn, Harvard, Caltech)
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)