Statement 1 : X > Y^2
Since y^2 > 0 for all Y, we can conclude that
X > 0 We do not know whether X and Y are integers or fractions. Hence we cannot compare X and Y.
Statement 2 : X and Y are positive integers.
Obviously insufficient.
Combining both,
X > |Y| and X>0
Thus sufficient to see that X>Y
IMHO it is C.