The solution is E.
The question could be modified to say, is y>x?
from I: insufficient
from II: x+y=1 : insufficient
combining both we have,
x+y=1 and y>0
but we could have x=.5 and y=.5 or x=-1 y=2
so its not sure to say that y>x.
Had it been said that x,y are integers, then C would be the correct answer.